The Evolution of Freemasonry's 3 Degree System

The transformation of Freemasonry from a two-degree to a three-degree system represents one of the most profound yet understudied developments our history. This evolutionary leap, occurring primarily in the early 18th century, not only restructured our institution but fundamentally reshaped how generations of Masons would understand the very nature of the Craft

In this episode of Daily Masonic Progress, we will understand why this historical development is not merely academic but essential for modern Freemasons because it:

• Reveals purpose in our ceremonies—the three degrees evolved from the three classes of Fellowcrafts, giving deeper meaning to what might otherwise seem like arbitrary rituals.

• Demonstrates Freemasonry's adaptability—our evolution from a two-degree system with hierarchical classes to today's structure shows how the Craft maintains its essence while responding to changing times.

• Illuminates our philosophical framework—each degree builds purposefully upon the previous one, creating a coherent journey from moral instruction through intellectual development to philosophical maturity.

• Connects us to a living tradition—what might appear as rigid adherence to ancient forms is actually a dynamic tradition carefully refined by generations of thoughtful Masons.

By the end, you will know why the three-degree system, complemented by the Installation Ceremony, represents centuries of development that continues to offer relevant wisdom and guidance in the modern world.

---

The Foundation of Masonic Degrees

The stonemasons' guilds of medieval Europe provide the foundation for what would eventually become modern Freemasonry. These operative masons, responsible for constructing the magnificent cathedrals and castles that still stand today, organised themselves into structured guilds with strict hierarchies and systems of knowledge transmission. The earliest documentary evidence of these operative lodges, including the Regius Manuscript (circa 1390) and the Cooke Manuscript (circa 1410), reveals a craft already rich in tradition and symbolism.

In these early operative lodges, the system of degrees served a practical purpose. The Entered Apprentice degree represented the beginning of a mason's journey, typically a young man apprenticed to a master for a period of seven years. During this time, apprentices learned the fundamental skills of the craft: how to cut stone, use basic tools, understand elementary geometry, and follow the discipline required by the profession. Operatively, they performed the physical labour of quarrying, cutting, and basic shaping of stones. Speculatively, this degree emphasised moral development, obedience to authority, and the initial lessons of morality and virtue.

The Fellowcraft degree marked the completion of apprenticeship and elevation to the status of a fully qualified craftsman. Operatively, Fellowcrafts possessed advanced skills in stone cutting, architectural design, and the mathematics necessary for complex construction. They could work independently, command higher wages, and travel freely between building sites—hence the term "travelling men" or "journeymen." Speculatively, this degree centred on intellectual development through the study of the Liberal Arts and Sciences, as highlighted in the Regius Manuscript, which emphasised their role in creating well-rounded craftsmen.

What is less commonly understood is that within the Fellowcraft degree existed a sophisticated hierarchy of three distinct classes, each with specific responsibilities and privileges:

1. The Working Class comprised the majority of Fellowcrafts who had mastered the practical skills of masonry but primarily worked as craftsmen executing the designs of others.

2. The Superior Class or Overseers possessed greater knowledge and skill, supervising the work of others and ensuring quality and adherence to plans.

3. The Ruling Class, exemplified by the three Grand Masters of Masonic tradition—King Solomon, Hiram King of Tyre, and Hiram Abiff—held the ultimate authority in the design, management, and governance of the craft.

This three-class system within the Fellowcraft degree contained the seeds that would eventually grow into our modern three-degree system. Early lodge records reveal that this distinction was operational long before the formal establishment of the Third Degree as we know it today.

The Transition to Speculative Masonry

As cathedral building declined in the late Renaissance period, operative lodges began admitting non-craftsmen—"accepted" or "speculative" masons—who were attracted to the fraternity's moral teachings, symbolism, and social aspects. This gradual transformation accelerated throughout the 17th century, particularly in Scotland and later in England.

The Edinburgh Register House Manuscript of 1696 provides our earliest detailed record of Masonic ritual, describing the "Mason Word" ceremony for Entered Apprentices. By this time, the two-degree system was firmly established, with members progressing from Entered Apprentice to Fellowcraft. However, the seeds of change were already apparent.

The formation of the Premier Grand Lodge of England in 1717 marked a pivotal moment in this evolution. Four London lodges united to form this first Grand Lodge, formalising the transition from operative to primarily speculative Masonry. This period coincided with the Enlightenment, when philosophical inquiry, scientific advancement, and interest in ancient wisdom flourished—creating fertile ground for Freemasonry's symbolic system to develop beyond its operative origins.

Dr John Theophilus Desaguliers, the third Grand Master of the Premier Grand Lodge and a prominent scientist, is credited with playing a significant role in the development of the Third Degree. His intellectual background in natural philosophy and interest in ancient mysteries likely influenced the deeper philosophical dimensions that would characterise the Master Mason degree.

During the 1720s, evidence began to emerge of a new, more elaborate degree developing within Freemasonry. The Airlie MS from Scotland, dated around 1726, contains references to a three-degree system, suggesting this evolution was occurring simultaneously in multiple jurisdictions. Meanwhile, minutes from various lodges began to mention "Masters' Lodges" conducting work distinct from that done in Fellowcraft lodges.

This period also saw the emergence of competing traditions. The "Moderns" (associated with the Premier Grand Lodge) initially showed ambivalence towards the emerging Third Degree, while other groups, later called the "Ancients," embraced and promoted it as essential to Masonic tradition. This tension created competing narratives about the legitimacy and proper place of the new degree.

The three-class system of Fellowcrafts was also evolving. As speculative elements gained prominence, the Working Class remained focused on the practical application of Masonic symbols, while the Superior Class developed deeper philosophical interpretations of these symbols. The Ruling Class, meanwhile, increasingly emphasised leadership, governance, and the preservation of esoteric knowledge.

What had once been divisions within a single degree were gradually transforming into a split of the second degree into two separate degrees, each with its own distinctive ceremonies, symbols, and lessons. This transformation did not occur uniformly or overnight but rather evolved through a process of innovation, adoption, and refinement that would continue for decades.

The Establishment of the Third Degree

The pivotal moment in this evolutionary process came with the formal establishment of the Master Mason degree as distinct from the Fellowcraft degree. While no single date marks this transition, substantial evidence suggests it was largely complete by the 1730s–1740s. This development represented not merely an administrative change but a fundamental transformation in how Masonry conceived its own purpose and teachings.

At the heart of this transformation was the story of Hiram Abiff, the master architect of King Solomon's Temple and his legend became the centrepiece of the new Master Mason degree. The introduction of this legend was revolutionary. It transformed Masonic ritual from a primarily instructional process to a profound initiatory experience where candidates symbolically experienced the story. This represented a significant departure from the more straightforward ceremonies of the Entered Apprentice and Fellowcraft degrees.

This development can be understood as the formalisation of what had previously been the Superior Class within the Fellowcraft degree into its own distinct degree—the Master Mason. The new degree incorporated deeper esoteric elements, more complex symbolism, and philosophical teachings about mortality and self-knowledge that had not been explicit in the earlier two-degree system.

Documentary evidence from this period shows the Third Degree rapidly gaining popularity and recognition. Samuel Prichard's "Masonry Dissected" (1730) contains one of the earliest public exposures of the three-degree system, including references to the Hiramic Legend. By 1738, when the second edition of Anderson's Constitutions was published, the three-degree system was acknowledged, though it was still not universally practised.

What made this transformation particularly significant was how it redistributed the original three classes of Fellowcrafts across the new degree structure:

1. The Working Class of Fellowcrafts became aligned with the modern Fellowcraft (Second) Degree

2. The Superior Class was elevated to the new Master Mason (Third) Degree,

3. The Ruling Class elevated into the Third Degree, but remained somewhat separate before eventually evolving into what would become the Installed Master, though this development would take longer to fully materialise.

This restructuring represented a fundamental shift in how Masonic progression was understood. Rather than advancement within a single degree (Fellowcraft) with three levels of attainment, Masons now progressed through three distinct degrees, each with its own ceremony, symbols, and lessons.

The Moderns vs Ancients

Following the establishment of the Third Degree, Freemasonry entered a period of refinement and formalisation. The conflict between the "Moderns" and "Ancients" Grand Lodges continued, with ritual differences being one of many points of contention. The "Ancients" generally favoured more elaborate ceremonies and emphasised the importance of the Royal Arch as a completion of the Third Degree, while the "Moderns" were initially more conservative in their approach.

During this period, the concept of the Ruling Class evolved into what we now know as the Installed Master. The earliest documented installation ceremony dates to 1722, when the Duke of Wharton established a new lodge. However, this ceremony initially received limited recognition, as Fellowcrafts were still permitted to serve as Masters of lodges in many jurisdictions.

The installation ceremony gradually gained prominence throughout the 18th century. The "Moderns" introduced a ceremony that communicated secrets and modes of recognition specific to Installed Masters, creating what became known as the "Inner Workings." This distinguished Installed Masters from other Master Masons, granting them the authority to preside over lodge meetings and access esoteric knowledge reserved for lodge leaders.

The "Ancients," meanwhile, viewed the installation ceremony as an essential part of Masonic tradition, emphasising the continuity of leadership and the transmission of authority. This difference in approach contributed to the ongoing rivalry between the two Grand Lodges.

A significant resolution came with the merger of the "Moderns" and "Ancients" in 1813 to form the United Grand Lodge of England. The Articles of Union explicitly recognised "pure Antient Masonry" as consisting of three degrees—Entered Apprentice, Fellowcraft, and Master Mason—along with the Holy Royal Arch. This merger helped standardise the three-degree system and the installation ceremony across English Freemasonry, although regional variations persisted.

In Scottish Freemasonry, the installation ceremony was formally adopted much later, around 1872, demonstrating how these developments occurred at different rates in various jurisdictions. Nevertheless, by the mid-19th century, the three-degree system, complemented by the ceremony of installation, had become the standard structure of Craft Freemasonry throughout much of the world.

This period of refinement completed the transformation of the original three-class Fellowcraft system into the modern structure we recognise today.

The Modern Three-Degree Structure

The three-degree system that emerged from this historical process represents a coherent philosophical journey that preserves the essence of operative masonry while expanding its speculative dimensions. Each degree now occupies a distinct place in a Mason's development, with clear parallels to the original class structure.

The modern Entered Apprentice degree continues to represent the beginning of the Masonic journey. Operatively, it reflects the apprentice's introduction to the basic tools and skills of masonry. Speculatively, it focuses on moral development, ethical conduct, and the foundational virtues required for further advancement. The candidate is introduced to the basic symbolism of the Craft and begins to understand the allegorical nature of Masonic teaching.

The Fellowcraft degree, aligned with what was once the Working Class of Fellowcrafts, now emphasises intellectual development and the practical application of Masonic principles. Operatively, it represents the journeyman's ability to apply advanced skills and techniques. Speculatively, its focus on the Liberal Arts and Sciences encourages the pursuit of knowledge and understanding. The Fellowcraft is taught to observe, analyse, and apply the lessons of Masonry in daily life.

The Master Mason degree, evolved from the Superior Class, represents the culmination of the Craft degrees. Operatively, it reflects the master craftsman's comprehensive knowledge and ability to design and oversee construction. Speculatively, it explores profound themes of mortality, fidelity and the Hiramic Legend.

Finally, the Installation Ceremony and the status of Installed Master preserve what was once the Ruling Class's role. Operatively, this represents the master builder's authority to direct the work of the lodge. Speculatively, it emphasises leadership, governance, and the preservation of Masonic tradition. The Installed Master becomes a representative of King Solomon that enable him to rule and govern his lodge effectively.

The Importance of Understanding This Historical Evolution

Why should modern Freemasons concern themselves with this historical development? Far from being merely an academic exercise, understanding the evolution of the degree system offers several valuable benefits to contemporary Masons.

It provides context and meaning to familiar ceremonies. When a Mason understands that the Third Degree evolved from the three classes of Fellowcrafts, ritualistic elements that might otherwise seem arbitrary take on new significance. It illuminates the coherent philosophical structure underpinning the degrees. Each stage builds upon the previous one, creating a unified system of moral and philosophical education that guides Masons from moral instruction through intellectual development to philosophical maturity—a progression as relevant today as when it was first developed.